How do messages get around the internet when nobody is in charge?
I developed an activity to simulate the TCP/IP networking protocol, along with code to generate individual roles in a classroom (or school-wide!) simulation.
In the network simulation, each student will play the role of a node on a network (gateway nodes are on two networks). In the classroom, this means that students will be scattered around the room, sitting on the floor, holding onto a loop of rope (gateway nodes hold two loops).
Any node may generate a request by filling out a data packet and then handing it to another node she is connected to by rope. The FROM and TO fields of the data packet must contain an IP address. The MESSAGE field may contain whatever fits into the box. For example:
-------------------------------------- TO: 101.100.100 FROM: 102.103.100 MESSAGE: What is Lulu's IP address? --------------------------------------
When a node receives a request, she should look at the TO field. If the request is for her, she should write a response back to the sender and throw away the request. If the request is not for her, she should pass it along to the next person.
Some nodes have special responsibilities. The nameservers have a lookup table, translating peoples’ names into IP addresses. When the nameservers receives a request for a name lookup, she should look up that person’s name and return a response containing that person’s name. Gateway nodes are responsible for deciding which network they should forward requests to. Each gateway node is provided with a subnet mask--a pattern she can use to determine whether a request belongs on her network. If a request matches the pattern, it should be sent along the subnetwork; otherwise it should be sent along the main network.
Encourage the participants to send messages to whomever they want. Sometimes I also encourage participants to mess with the system and see what they can get away with. The goal is to figure out the basic mechanics of communication. At the end of the first round, a discussion should uncover the following attributes of the system:
- You have to query the nameserver before you can send messages to someone new.
- Packets can take different amounts of time to get to their destination
- There is no way to really know who the message came from. It is possible to spoof other IP addresses.
- It is possible to see what other people are talking about if you look at packets that are not yours. A really malicious agent could replace packets with new packets, and neither the sender nor the receiver would be able to detect it.
If the participants are ready for a greater challenge, ask them to transmit longer messages to each other, which don’t fit in a single packet. Before this second round, lead a discussion about creating a protocol to transmit a message broken into several packets, a means of putting the messages back in order, and a means of re-requesting any packet that gets dropped.
After the simulation, put students in small groups with different node types, so they can discuss their various experiences. If you try this with your students, I would love to hear how it went.